Nexant, Inc.
1,4-Butanediol/THF
Keywords: supply, demand, nexant, chemical, forecast, analysis, petrochemical, report


Full Report Price: $6,500.00
Sections: starting at $100.00
Delivery: Immediate Online Access
Publication Date: 23-JAN-04

Format: PDF document  PDF Electronic Document
Add to Cart image

-- or --       



Report Description

Background

The global butanediol (BDO) market was around 0.78 million tons in 2002, and demand growth is estimated to average 4.0 percent per year to 2015. As alternative technologies can be used to make tetrahydrofuran (BDO dehydration) and ?-butyrolactone (GBL), future demand growth will be driven by polybutylene terephthalate (PBT), thermoplastic polyurethanes (TPU), and copolyester ether (COPE) production. Historically BDO has been consumed mainly in developed economies, but in future the East Asian market will be increasingly important. The East Asian market is partly supply-led such that if local supply is available new derivative business are likely to start-up also. In contrast, the global THF market was around 273 000 tons in 2002 and projected to grow at around 5.6 percent per year driven by PTMEG demand for spandex fibers, COPE and TPU. East Asia too is a strong growth region for THF. In terms of global supply the availability of competitively priced butanes and access to technology will continue to encourage new investment in BDO, THF and derivatives for export.

BDO technology has evolved greatly from the original process developed by Walter Reppe for IG Farben in the 1930s. The requirements of handling acetylene meant that for many years the production of BDO and derivatives could only be performed by a select few. The perception of the value of BDO and its derivatives THF, GBL, etc., spurred substantial efforts in new process developments that came to fruition in a number of commercial processes, including butadiene acetoxylation and allyl alcohol (from propylene oxide) hydroformylation, together with various routes from n-butane via maleic anhydride/maleic acid. Not only have the technologies evolved but also the scale of production, with new worldscale units exceeding capacities of 100 000 tons per year or more.

The first non-acetylene BDO process to be commercialized in the 1970s was the Mitsubishi butadiene acetoxylation, developed as a swing BDO and THF technology. During the 1980s, Arco developed its propylene oxide process via allyl alcohol and commercialized it in the United States in 1990. At this point no technology had been developed simply for license. This was changed by the development by Davy Mckee Ltd. of the first maleic anhydride process, which was licensed to Tonen and Shinwa (now Korea-PTG). In the early 1990s, Sisas developed its own maleic technology for BDO/THF and GBL production.

Existing technologies continue to evolve, while new processes for THF, like the Eastman butadiene epoxidation process, await a commercial opportunity. However, of keen interest today is the potential to develop and commercialize a new route to BDO from glucose via biotransformation through fermentation with a genetically modified Escherichia coli strain to succinic acid and subsequent hydrogenation to BDO.

Markets

As Figure 1 shows, butanediol is a valuable chemical intermediate for the production of high performance polymers, solvents and fine chemicals. The BDO value chain has three main branches - polymers, tetrahydrofuran derivatives and ?-butyrolactone derivatives. BDO is used directly in PBT, TPU and COPE production. When converted to THF and subsequently polytetramethylene ether glycol (PTMEG) the spandex industry is added to the markets served.

The production of GBL provides the feedstock for N-methyl-2-pyrrolidone and 2-pyrrolidone as well as serving agrochemical and intermediates markets. NMP is a high performance solvent for extraction processes and increasingly for the electronics industry. 2-Pyrrolidone is an intermediate for pharmaceutical production and via further reaction to N-vinyl-2-pyrrolidone for a family of high value polyvinyl pyrrolidone polymers.

Cost Analysis

In developing cost models for BDO and THF production by technology, it is important to tie the technology within a reasonable commercial platform or the results can be misleading. As an example illustrated in Figure 2, when all elements of the Reppe process are combined, namely acetylene, formaldehyde, methanol (from acetylene by-product synthesis gas) and BDO, the power and steam consumption justifies integrated power and steam cogeneration. With this in mind estimates for integrated cases have been considered alongside more typical analysis methodologies for BDO production. The analysis reveals certain aspects of BDO and THF production cost that otherwise would be hidden.

This report presents production economics for seven petrochemical BDO processes, with some processes further showing the effects of scale and feedstock integration. Comparison is made to a conceptual biochemical process. THF economics are estimated for six processes at typical plant scales and characteristic feedstocks.

Table 1 shows the processes for which detailed economics are included in the report.

Table 1:
BDO/THF Economics Included in Report

BDOTHF
  • Reppe, Standalone
  • Reppe
  • Reppe, Integrated
  • Mitsubishi
  • Mitsubishi
  • BASF
  • Lyondell, Standalone
  • Pentose
  • Lyondell, Integrated
  • DuPont
  • Darien, Standalone
  • Eastman (developmental)
  • Darien, Integrated
 
  • Davy
 
  • Eurodiol
 
  • BP/Lurgi
 
  • Biotransformation (conceptual)
 

Markets

Global BDO markets are characterized in the report by end use and by region, with supply and demand projections to 2015. Parallel data are presented for THF on a global basis.

A chart lays out degree of downstream integration for producers of BDO and derivatives, as well as highlighting the positions of the major merchant consumers of these materials.

Figure 1 Butanediol Value Chain
(Illustrative)


IMAGE: CHEM EQ PERPN027-1

Figure 2 Reppe Butanediol Process Infrastructure
(Illustrative)


IMAGE: CHEM EQ PERPN027-2



Table of Contents: 1,4-Butanediol/THF
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Introduction
TECHNOLOGY EVOLUTION
Overview
Phase One Acetylene - The Early Years
Figure 2.1 Acetylene, Butanediol and Buna-S SBR Production
Phase Two - The New Challengers
Phase Three - Industry Commoditization through Technology
Figure 2.2 n-Butane-Based Butanediol Technologies
Figure 2.3 Non n-Butane-Based Butanediol Technologies
BUTANEDIOL VALUE CHAIN
Figure 2.4 The Butanediol Value Chain
METHODOLOGY AND STUDY OUTLINE
Commercial Technology
PROCESSES FOR 1,4-BUTANEDIOL
Acetylene/Formaldehyde (Reppe Concept)
Figure 3.1 Synthesis of 1,4-Butanediol from Acetylene and Formaldehyde
Figure 3.2 Two Step Hydrogenation of 1,4-Butynediol to 1,4-Butanediol
Mitsubishi Chemical Butadiene Acetoxylation
Figures 3.3 1,4-Acetoxybutene Production Via Butadiene Acetoxylation
Lyondell Propylene Oxide Route
Figure 3.5 Propylene Oxide Isomerization to Allyl Alcohol
Figure 3.6 4-Hydroxybutyraldehyde Via Allyl Alcohol Hydroformylation
Darien Propylene Acetoxylation/Hydroformylation
Figure 3.8 Allyl Alcohol Via Propylene Acetoxylation and Back Cracking
Davy Process Technology - 1,4-Butanediol Process using Maleic Anhydride
Figure 3.9 Simplified Worldscale Crude Maleic Anhydride Production from Normal Butane
Figure 3.10 Davy Process Maleic Anhydride Esterification and Hydrogenation
Eurodiol (Now BASF) Concept Based on Maleic Anhydride
Figure 3.12 Schematic View of Eurodiol 1,4-Butanediol and Derivatives Process
Table 3.1 Eurodiol Butanediol Process (mass balance summary)
BP/Lurgi Geminox from n-Butane via Maleic Acid
Figure 3.13 BP Lurgi Geminox Fluid Bed Maleic Acid Production
PROCESSES FOR TETRAHYDROFURAN
Dehydration of 1,4-Butanediol
Figure 3.15 Tetrahydrofuran Via Butanediol Dehydration
Mitsubishi Chemical Butadiene Acetoxylation
Figure 3.16 Mitsubish Process: Tetrahydrofuran from 1,4-Diacetoxybutene
DuPont Transport Bed Concept
Figure 3.17 DuPont Process: Transport Bed Oxidation of N-Butane to Maleic Acid
Table 3.3 Design Parameters Used for Maleic Anhydride Reactor
Figure 3.18 DuPont Process: Conversion of Maleic Acid into Tetrahydrofuran
Figure 3.19 Fufural Extraction from Pentose-Containing Agricultural Sources
Pentose/Furfural Approach
Figure 3.20 Fufural Conversion into Tetrahydrofuran
Emerging Petrochemical Technology
BUTADIENE EPOXIDATION
Process Chemistry
Process Description
Figure 4.1 Conceptual Eastman Tetrahydrofuran Process: 3.4 Epoxy-Butene Production from 1,3-Butadiene
Figure 4.2 Conceptual Eastman Tetrahydrofuran Process: Tetrahydrofuran Production from 3,4 Epoxy-Butane
LINDE/YUKONG ACETYLENE BASED PROCESS
Introduction
Table 4.1 Linde/Yukong Reaction Conditions
Reppe Chemistry
Figure 4.3 Conceptual Linde/Yukong Process for Butandiol Acetylene Reaction System
Butynediol Hydrogenation
Opportunities
Figure 4.4 Conceptual Linde/Yukong Process for Butandiol Hydrogenation System
BASF N-BUTANE TO TETRAHDYROFURAN PROCESS
Figure 4.5 Conceptual BASF N-Butane to Tetrahydrofuran Process (Front End Only)
SUMMARY
Biotransformation Via Succinic Acid
OVERVIEW
Current Investigators
Commentary on Process Chemistry
PROCESS CONCEPT
Fermentation
Succinic Acid Recovery
Figure 5.1 Electrodialysis in Cationic Mode
Figure 5.2 Conceptual Biotransformation Process for ButanSection Figure Caption
Figure 5.3 Conceptual Biotransformation Process for Butanediol Via Succinic Acid - Work Up Step
Conversion to Butanediol
Figure 5.4 Conceptual Biotransformation Process for Butanediol Via Succinic Acid - Hydrogenation Step
FURTHER POTENTIAL IMPROVEMENTS
Fermentation
Succinic Acid Neutralization
SUMMARY
Process Economics
OVERVIEW
Table 6.1 Feedstocks and Product Prices
Table 6.2 Utilities and Manpower Charges
TECHNO-ECONOMICS FOR COMMERCIAL BUTANEDIOL PROCESSES
Acetylene/Formaldehyde (Reppe Concept)
Figure 6.1 Integrated Reppe Butanediol Process
Table 6.3 Cost of Production Estimate for: 1,4-Butanediol
Table 6.4 Cost of Production Estimate for: 1,4-Butanediol
Table 6.5 Cost of Production Estimate for: 1,4-Butanediol
Table 6.6 Cost of Production Estimate for: 1,4-Butanediol
Table 6.7 Cost of Production Estimate for: 1,4-Butanediol
Table 6.8 Cost of Production Estimate for: 1,4-Butanediol
Table 6.9 Cost of Production Summary for 1,4-Butanediol
Figure 6.2 Cost of Production Summary for 1,4-Butanediol
Mitsubishi Chemical Butadiene Acetoxylation
Lyondell Propylene Oxide Route
Darien Propylene Acetoxylation/Hydroformylation Route
Table 6.10 Cost of Production Estimate for: 1,4-Butanediol
Table 6.11 Cost of Production Estimate for: 1,4-Butanediol

 

Nexant ChemSystems Reports

Browse other Nexant research reports by category:

Process Evaluation/Research Planning - PERP

Petroleum and Petrochemical Economics - PPE

PolyOlefin Planning Service - POPS

Topical Reports

About Nexant

Nexant, Inc. helps clients unlock the value of their energy assets by enabling them to make informed decisions with greater confidence, speed, and reliability. Our goal is to help clients sucessfully meet the challenges they face in the global energy market.

Home  Browse  Search  E-mail  Content Map
Nexant, Inc., 101 Second Street, 11th Floor, San Francisco CA
Tel: (415) 369-1000    Fax: (415) 369-9700